Home » The Cultured Critic

Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band Dethroned As Best Album Of All Time

by Erin Darling 26 June 2013 464 views One Comment E-mail Erin Darling

Entertainment Weekly announced it’s list of the 100 all-time greatest pop culture rankings of everything from movies, TV shows, to music.

While perennial favorite  of the critics, “Citizen Kane” topped the list of the greatest movies (shocker), I was a little more surprised to see the publication’s choice for top album. Though most wouldn’t be stunned to hear that an album from The Beatles topped the list, it was not “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band” that claimed the number spot.

Though called the most influential and famous rock album ever made, and being named the greatest album of all time by the 1st edition of Colin Larkin’s All Time Top 1000 Albums, the National Association of Recording Merchandisers Definitive 200, and Rolling Stone magazine’s 500 Greatest Albums Of All Time, ”Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band” was not only bypassed for the top spot, but also didn’t even crack Entertainment Weekly’s top 5.

“Sgt. Pepper” was dethroned by another Beatles album, “Revolver.”


As a life-long Beatles fan, this is interesting to me for many reasons. First of all, I applaud EW for it’s choice to crown “Revolver,” knocking “Sgt. Pepper” off it’s pop pedestal. While I’d never attempt to deny the pervasive musical influence, prowess, and well-roundedness of this album, my reasons for commending this choice are a bit more personal.

It all comes down to one question. “What’s your favorite album?” It’s always the first thing I ask whenever I meet a fellow Beatles fan.

I’ve never spent more listening to, discussing, or defending any album than I have “Revolver.” My obsession started in high school when I moved from loving the songs that initially boosted The Beatles to international fame, to the tracks that established them as artists, revolutionaries, and game-changers in terms of what popular music could be. That’s when I found “Revolver” and swiftly fell in love with George Harrison’s burgeoning songwriting skills, and the sounds of his sitar.

Ever since that day, “Revolver” rose up the ranks to become my personal favorite album from The Beatles (and also of all time) for an overwhelming plethora of reasons. Some personal, some professional.

As a fan, “Revolver” is special to me because it so clearly represents the start of a new direction in the band’s musical progression. In my opinion, it was when The Beatles really started sounding like The Beatles and the shift is palpable. As a critic and pop culture junkie, this album is noteworthy due to it’s revolutionary use of artificial double tracking (ADT), tape-looping, and arguably spearheading the psychedelic genre. The Beatles were experimenting with techniques and ideas that were unheard of, and/or not found in mainstream pop music in 1966,  paving the way and opening the synapses for their next studio album, 1967′s “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band.”

I’ve spent many a bar night engrossed in this conversation, defending why I choose “Revolver” over “Sgt. Pepper,” often ending in frustration, and blowing off steam with another Jameson on the rocks. When it comes to The Beatles, I’ve learned to accept that “Sgt. Pepper” will almost always be the popular choice while “Revolver” falls behind. Historically, critics agree, giving “Revolver” 3rd place on Rolling Stone, and listing it at number 42 on the Definitive 200. And while it actually bested later editions of the All Time Top 1000 Albums, we can’t forget that the first edition gave “Sgt. Pepper” the top honor.

In conclusion, EW, I commend you for recognizing “Revolver.” Though selfish my reasons may be, I’m not sorry for this pop culture soliloquy. Because personal reasons aside, “Revolver” is certainly worthy of the honor.

Rounding out EW’s top 5 greatest albums of all time:

5. London Calling – The Clash

4. Thriller – Michael Jackson

3. Exile on Main Street – The Rolling Stones

2. Purple Rain – Prince

1. Revolver – The Beatles

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...

One Comment »

Leave your response!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.